Mind · Reasoning
EpistemicCascade
A conclusion inherits the verification assurance of its weakest load-bearing premise.
Definition
Mechanism
Before an assertion crosses a boundary (a message, a commit, an irreversible action), enumerate the premises it load-bears on and grade the assurance of each: Independent (a Check by a method other than the one that produced the premise), Self (checked only by the producing process), or None (Assumption). A Check yields a Status; this pattern grades what that outcome is worth given how it was obtained, so a Verified premise carrying only Self assurance does not raise the closure. The assertion's assurance is the minimum over that closure; reasoning quality above a weakly assured premise cannot raise it. To upgrade, select the premise with the highest ratio of downstream cost to checking cost and apply Verification by an independent method, then re-derive. Where no check is possible before the boundary, the assertion carries its assurance explicitly instead of borrowing confidence from fluency (EpistemicCalibrate), and BeliefTracking records the pending premises so later evidence can settle them.
Preconditions
- The assertion's load-bearing premises can be enumerated.
- The boundary crossing is identifiable before it happens.
Postconditions
- Every boundary-crossing assertion carries an explicit assurance grade.
- The weakest load-bearing premise is either independently verified or declared.
Invariants
- Assurance(conclusion) never exceeds min(Assurance(premise)) over its load-bearing premises.
- A premise checked only by the process that produced it carries Self assurance at most; Independent requires a method that did not produce it.
- Assurance changes only through verification events, never through repetition or restatement.
Risks
Failure modes
Polishing reasoning downstream of a weakly assured premise
rigor above does not repair assurance below.
Verifying the cheapest premise instead of the most load-bearing one.
Confidence laundering
an assertion crosses a boundary and the reader assigns it an assurance it never earned.
Relationships
Builds on
References
Infrastructure
Provisional truth
Note what you believed before and after
Infrastructure
Side-effect-free observational verification yielding Verified/Falsified/Unknown
Structural confidence degradation
Infrastructure
Graded verification outcome: Verified, Falsified, or Unknown
Confirming alignment with truth or spec
Used by
References
Adopt a perspective for what it opens, and check its claims on a separate ledger
