{
  "handle": "Critique",
  "mechanism": "Analyzes a target {{datum}} against specific {{criteria}} and generates a structured {{assessment}}. Unlike judgment (which yields a scalar), Critique produces descriptive, actionable advice.",
  "gloss": "Qualitative feedback generation",
  "failure_modes": [
    "Nitpicking: Focusing on trivial details while missing structural flaws.",
    "Vague Praise: Generic feedback that offers no actionable path.",
    "Projection: Critiquing the artifact for not being what the critic would have built."
  ],
  "invariants": [
    "Feedback must be descriptive, not just scalar.",
    "Must reference specific criteria."
  ],
  "_meta": {
    "tier": 1,
    "ring": 1,
    "supersedes": [
      "sema:Critique#mh:SHA-256:3e00cb143ce745ed77a29af93416808b848b2a2d9749245b777ad90901aa4ba8",
      "sema:Critique#mh:SHA-256:0254558d2c0740261b93c246bfa4eebc279356bec6c2a039fe799fdfc2761237",
      "sema:Critique#mh:SHA-256:77f2544f9e6978b453ac8eaec66c792304025fb778a78bf0c4dac39cae28d074"
    ],
    "path": [
      "Mind",
      "Reasoning"
    ],
    "related": [
      "Critiquedrift#bd7c"
    ]
  },
  "sema_id": "sema:Critique#mh:SHA-256:646b71acb10a6b7f0874f3d5c7977c44d253f29f9c1231c974d85c7fba131980",
  "sema_ref": "Critique#646b",
  "sema_stub": "646b",
  "dependencies": {
    "accepts": {
      "criteria": "sema:Criteria#mh:SHA-256:92ab804441f5ff5307c6e45905818372e6159c4bd64d264ac7fddd6705de8acb",
      "datum": "sema:Datum#mh:SHA-256:f90456c1067ac5db4e9825a82a22bc58086022f8acd0d0f63fdfeaeb6be2e937"
    },
    "yields": {
      "assessment": "sema:Assessment#mh:SHA-256:167a9fa1717f905acbbabb8d5d64b19001b3684a4057f252ed67615ce022dba4"
    }
  },
  "sema_layer": "Mind",
  "sema_category": "Reasoning",
  "used_by": {
    "references": {
      "Critiquedrift": "sema:Critiquedrift#mh:SHA-256:bd7c044fc9f6b5f9b18dcccc3916f6a56d0e876b4b87d8c2ea5cb4447ff6e36c",
      "Jester": "sema:Jester#mh:SHA-256:1becc880f882693433654cc3572a4bf812d375000f0ae21640e5775a86b74005",
      "Reflexion": "sema:Reflexion#mh:SHA-256:81eb9140703ea95f53556741df731af84c1cada66cc1e0f3a1d88e4de5fe54d8",
      "StructuralCoaching": "sema:StructuralCoaching#mh:SHA-256:4552c90190484bb0ec782a05f03f6259c37610dca851ba165a9ab4074f0ede51"
    },
    "composes_with": {
      "Refine": "sema:Refine#mh:SHA-256:2952467a9d3eb809c6131d59e1047a3a4aa296d32dcd38a82c0204b5cd8d16a6",
      "SteelmanCheck": "sema:SteelmanCheck#mh:SHA-256:b004eb6d85a184da7f9bb7fc06d011bc869f6eb6ad1061f30cbbbcc4c2b8f6aa"
    }
  }
}